Skip to main content

Notes from a Sauternes tasting

Drinking good Sauternes can be moving. Is it because of its great power of expression, its luscious sweetness, its fathomless depth? Or is it because I hardly ever drink Sauternes on a 'normal' day? In a way Sauternes appears like a Harp does in a concert: at the highlight. In an attempt to have a great evening last forever, we return to our cellar to dive up one of our golden treasures. Nine out of ten bottles are enjoyed within this best possible environment: among friends, who are all reluctant to call it a day.

Château Climens and Château Suduiraut
Most bottles that I enjoy are lonely bottles. For example one to wrap up the evening, or one as the very last bottle of a tasting. It's not a deliberate thing, but I am not drinking Sauternes every week, or every month... but after the tasting of last weekend I know that I will shift my attention – again – to this great classic region. If only it were to experiment with new wine-food pairings; there are so many more possibilities than the obliged combination with cheese for desert. Just to mention one of the inspiring things that were told during this afternoon – I do not remember if it was one of the château owners who said this, or Sauternes connoisseur Bill Blatch, who introduced the producers at this tasting.

Bill BlatchBORDEAUX WINE MERCHANT BILL BLATCH (VINTEX). BLATCH IS SPECIALISED IN THE WINES FROM SAUTERNES, AND IS GENERALLY REGARDED AS ONE OF THE AUTHORITIES ON THIS SUBJECT.

The tasting that I'm talking about was organised by the Amsterdam-based wine merchant Ton Overmars. A great tasting with both a vertical aspect – comparing three vintages from one château – and two horizontal ones: comparing five different châteaux, and comparing the two appellations Barsac and Sauternes. We tasted 15 wines:

1. Château Climens (Barsac) 2005, 2002 and 1999
2. Château Coutet (Barsac) 2005, 2002 and 1999
3. Château Giraud (Sauternes) 2005, 2002 and 1998
4. Château Clos Haut-Peyraguey (Sauternes) 2005, 2003 and 1998
5. Château Suduiraut (Sauternes) 2005, 2002 and 1999

Baly, Vos, Overmars, Dedieu, LurtonFROM LEFT TO RIGHT: PHILIPPE BALY FROM CHATEAU COUTET, EDWIN VOS FROM POOT AGENTUREN, TON OVERMARS, CAROLINE DEDIEU FROM CHATEAU SUDUIRAUT AND BERENICE LURTON-THOMAS FROM CHATEAU CLIMENS. UNFORTUNATELY MISSING ON THESE PICTURES IS LAURE PLANTY FROM CHATEAU GUIRAUD.

The appellation Barsac lies directly north of Sauternes, at the other side of the small river Ciron, on lower grounds close to the river Garonne. The sediments that have been deposited onto the limestone subsoil – throughout the many many thousands of years – have here been largely taken away again by the river. Other than in Sauternes, where the limestone lies deeper, and where the vines grow on hills with gravel and pebbles. This accounts for a difference in the style of the wines. Barsac (which may also be called Sauternes or Barsac-Sauternes) produces wines that are slightly lighter than Sauternes.

After decades of misery in Sauternes (for a long time there was hardly any interest in the wines from this region, which understandably didn't have a positive effect on the quality of most wines) it is good to see that the region is fully back on track. The overall quality of the wines is high. My personal favourite is Clos Haut-Peyraguey, all three years of this wine are very good. It is just too bad that they just replaced their very characteristic label for a mediocre modern one. The old label of Clos Haut-Peyraguey has this convincing, forward and original typeface. Too bad, but well, what matters is what's behind the label.

Anthony Defives, cellar master Château Clos Haut-PeyragueyTHE TALENTED CELLAR MASTER ANTHONY DEFIVES WHO WORKS FOR MARTINE LANGLAIS-PAULY FROM CHATEAU CLOS HAUT-PEYRAGUEY.

All 2005s are really great; very rich with sometimes high amounts of residual sugar (e.g. Climens with 170 grams per litre, and a very impressive wine...). The 2005 vintage showed both wines of an outstanding quality, and the yields were much bigger than in 'normal' years. 2002 is a good vintage, more modest in character, often spicy. Especially Suduiraut gives a lot of pleasure. Within the 1998s and 1999s there is more variety in quality, with the best results it seems from the higher grounds.

Comments

Paul Conlon said…
Two questions -

Your view of the 2007 versus the 2009 vintages in terms of Botrytis content and secondly your opionon on the development of the 2001 vintage. Comments on the 2001 Lafaurie Peraguey are welcome.
David said…
Hi Paul, Sauternes 2007 is very good, 2009 I will taste soon in Bordeaux. Will write about that on the blog later. Best, David
Bill said…
David: The Overmars Sauternes tasting was a lot of fun, wasn't it? I really appreciated your enthusiasm too. We must do another one! I really agree about the 98s, 02s etc, and the 05s were - and still are - looking fabulous.
Bill Blatch
www.bordeauxgold.com

Popular posts from this blog

Bordeaux 2016 grootste aanraders

Tips Bordeaux 2016 - Evenals vorige jaar presenteer ik weer de hitparade, de hall of fame. Subjectief, en mag best tot verhitte discussies leiden, allemaal goed. Dit is wat we dit jaar vonden. Op deze apenrots alleen de rode wijnen.

De meer betaalbare wijnen, de kleinere châteaux, komen in een volgende posting aan bod. Evenals de witte wijnen. Per cijfer staan de wijnen alfabetisch. En de Top Tweede Wijnen Bordeaux 2016 staat onderaan.

Omissie: Gruaud Larose 2016 hebben we niet geproefd. Op de proeftafel stond een lege fles. Ook gemist helaas: Haut Batailley 2016. Meestal gaaf, maar François-Xavier Borie had 'm er dit jaar niet bij staan - tot nu toe werd deze wijn steevast samen gepresenteerd met de Grand Puy Lacoste.

20
Ausone 2016
Lafite Rothschild 2016
Margaux 2016
Petrus 2016

19½
Canon 2016
l’Eglise-Clinet 2016
Haut-Bailly 2016
Haut-Brion 2016
Latour 2016
Montrose 2016
Palmer 2016
Le Pin 2016
Pontet-Canet 2016
Vieux Château Certan 2016

19+
La Conseillante 2016
Domaine de Chevali…

Bordeaux 2016 kooptips linkeroever

Kooptips Bordeaux 2016 - de value-for-money killer 2016's ter linkerzijde van Gironde en Garonne - Leuk natuurlijk al die dure jongens (uit de vorige posting), maar wat zijn nou de wijnen die je straks makkelijk opentrekt, en waar je misschien extra van geniet omdat het ook nog eens zo'n leuk koopje was? We hebben de grootste aanraders op rij gezet. We volgen min of meer de volgorde van de lijst met ons aanbod.

Mauvesin Barton 2016 Moulis
Eigenlijk is dit geen killer wine. Geen tot nederigheid stemmend zwaargewicht die proevers besmuikt naar elkaar laat knikken, daarbij sjonge jonge mompelend of iets dergelijks. Nee, als hier iets of iemand bescheidenheid aan de dag legt dan is het de wijn zelf. Dit is een eerlijke, ingetogen Médoc met fijne klassieke trekken. Voornaam zonder gedoe. Mooi puur fruit, heel goed in balans. Elegant en sappig. En en bouche uitgesproken energiek. Kleine Barton waar je blij van wordt. Mauvesin Barton 2016.

Potensac 2016 Médoc
Uit de stal van Léoville l…

Bordeaux 2016 kooptips rechteroever

Kooptips Bordeaux 2016 - de value-for-money killer 2016's ter rechterzijde van Gironde en Garonne - Het heeft even geduurd, maar hier is dan de laatste posting met tips, de leukste betaalbare primeurs uit Saint-Emilion en Pomerol en omstreken. We volgen weer min of meer de volgorde van de lijst met ons aanbod.

Fonroque 2016 St-Emilion
Deze wijn hoort hier eigenlijk niet thuis. Als 'Grand Vin', deze biodynamische Grand Cru Classé van mooi terroir nabij de heuvel van St-Emilion (het dorp). Wél een wijn die ongehoord goed is én zeer betaalbaar. Mijn proefnotitie schudt Pavlov wakker, en dat midden op de dag. Expressief, rood fruitig en soepel. Intens, evenwichtig en met levendige zuren. Veel precisie en frisheid. En dan eindigt de notitie met het woord 'top'. Says it all. Klasse en evenwicht, zie daar deze jonge pure Fonroque 2016.

Grand Corbin Despagne 2016 St-Emilion
Nog zo'n geweldige verstekeling. Eveneens een heuse Grand Cru Classé, maar belangrijker: ook een b…