Skip to main content

Bordeaux 2010, my first impressions

Bordeaux 2010. People keep on asking me “And, is it better than 2009?” It is a notion that has clearly become planted in many heads: Bordeaux 2010 is a monumental vintage. Well done, Bordeaux marketeers, you did it again. But perhaps it’s true. Jan van Roekel and I tasted hundreds of wines, and, if I may speak for myself, I was impressed more than once.

Aurélien Valance from Château MargauxAurélien Valance, Château Margaux's Commercial Director: "For us the best Pavillon Rouge ever." The words sounded somewhat familiar to me...

About the “better” I wouldn’t know. Bordeaux 2010 is different from 2009. It's a vigorous and well-structured vintage. And yes, my feeling is that I found more balanced wines this year than the year before. I also encountered things that were not so nice, like crazy alcohol levels, and mouth torturing tannins. But there are definitely many exciting wines this year.

I hardly saw last year’s difficulties with respect to ripeness (too ripe, or on the other hand not enough, for details see my posting from last year). The combination of a dry and sunny summer on the one hand, and fairly moderate temperatures on the other have surely been very beneficial to the 2010s.

With the moderate temperatures, the grapes have very much kept their freshness. At the same time the long summer season has produced grapes with lots of… everything. The acidity is clearly one of the distinguishing features of Bordeaux 2010. I guess many of these wines will survive us.

This striking acidity that many 2010s possess can be impressive: for the best wines, in combination with a ripe tannic structure it highlights the mineral qualities of a wine – it’s the terroir facet of the jewel that is facing us these days, and there’s clearly much behind it too.

Alcohol also, and sometimes a lot. La Mission Haut-Brion at 15%, Troplong-Mondot at 15,8% to give two shocking examples. But it must be said, the alcohol doesn’t really stand out within the overall richness of these wines. Note that these voluminous examples do not belong to my personal favorites.

In the best cases the acidity is simply electrifying, in the positive sense of the word: many wines are very energetic and alive. And that’s something I like.

Bordeaux 2010 is very much a cabernet year (for a part due to problems with merlot this year) and the percentages used in the blend are very high. Personally I can’t really draw the conclusion that 2010, as a result, is a Left Bank year. I tasted some great Right Bankers (and had problems with quite a few Margaux’s actually).

The 2010 pitfall: some less talented producers made the mistake of playing too much with this impressive fruit. The best wines simply made themselves. What was harvested merely had to be fermented, and not much more. Winemakers who couldn’t contain themselves were the ones to make overextracted, hard wines. It simply was not a good idea to do too many pumping overs this year.

In the next posting(s) I will list my personal recommendations. People who follow me know what I’m looking for: purity, freshness, originality. What I do not like: over-extraction, overripeness, an excess use of oak, and make-up in general.

If you’re interested in the more technical details for Bordeaux 2010, and the details regarding the growing season, read the in-depth vintage report by Bill Blatch.

Talking about Bill Blatch: I shouldn't forget to mention Sauternes. I tasted some lovely wines here (e.g. loved the freshness of Guiraud, and Yquem was breathtaking). More about this later.

Finally one word about prices. I expect these to be on the same level as last year. But the wines that have gained much value during the last year, such as the second wines of the premier crus, will be released at a higher price. I wrote about this in detail in an earlier posting. The lower yields this year will help push up the price a bit I'm afraid.

Château Petit Bocq was the first wine to be released, this morning. The price is a modest 2,4% up in comparison to 2009. But it’s known that the prices of the petit châteaux do not move that much. I’m curious what the rest of this week will bring.

To be continued.


Steve Webb said…
Hi David

Better link to Bill's 2010 report is at - a colour pdf no less! Your impressions of the 2010 mirror Bill's and mine - some great wines but potentially some problem ones too! It was very early to taste this type of vintage and critic scores, in my opinion, should be taken with a pinch of salt at this stage. Even with the Sauternes (which were much more consistent) it took me 3-4 tastings to 'get' the vintage and appreciate the balance - essentially a lot of fruit is hiding/hidden at the moment but when you get a glimpse of it your breath can be taken away!
Roel van Gestel said…
Yet another grande année in Bdx. Last one I stocked up was the holy 2005 and compared to the sacred 2009 and probably glorious 2010 as well, '05 can be considered 'cheap'.
Still, I look forward to reading more on these babies. The high alcohol levels on the RB are worrying, though.
Winefridges and cellar are full anyway, but maybe one or two bottles for 'sentimental reasons' can always find a place....

Popular posts from this blog

Bordeaux 2017 aanraders - de grootste wijnen

Evenals vorig jaar geven we met plezier onze volstrekt subjectieve lijst met gaafste rode wijnen van het jaar. We hebben bijna alles geproefd van Bordeaux 2017, maar geen Petrus en Lafleur. Binnenkomen bij Petrus is zo'n gedoe dat we dat na jaren proeven maar laten voor wat het is. Lafleur pakken we volgend jaar graag weer mee. Maar zoals is te zien hebben we toch wel weer ons best gedaan.

Cheval Blanc 2017
Latour 2017
Léoville-las-Cases 2017
Palmer 2017
Vieux Château Certan 2017

Ausone 2017
Canon 2017
Haut-Bailly 2017
Lafite Rothschild 2017
l’Eglise-Clinet 2017
La Conseillante 2017
Le Pin 2017
Léoville Barton 2017
Margaux 2017
Montrose 2017
Pontet-Canet 2017

Beauséjour Duffau-Lagarrosse 2017
Clos Fourtet 2017
Cos d’Estournel 2017
Domaine de Chevalier rouge 2017
Grand Puy Lacoste 2017
Haut-Brion 2017
l’Evangile 2017
l’If 2017
La Mission Haut-Brion 2017
Les Carmes Haut-Brion 2017
Lynch Bages 2017
Mouton Rothschild 2017
Pavie Macquin 2017
Rauzan-Ségla 2017

Calon Ségur 20…

Bordeaux 2017 - het herrezen jaar

We zijn terug van vijf dagen proeven, een dikke 8 uur per dag Bordeaux 2017's proeven. Een ervaring rijker, zeker als je de wijnen meetelt die we in de avonden proefden, en dronken. Het meest bijzonder waren wel de Poujeaux 1928 en de Domaine de Chevalier rouge 1928. Ongelofelijke wijnen en een ongekende tijdreis van 90 jaar. Een bijkans mystieke ervaring.

Of wat te denken van de witte Latour Martillac 1948. Toen we een paar dagen later op het château de 2017's proefden hoorden we van de keldermeester dat er die week 2 van de 6 nog aanwezige flessen Blanc 1948 uit de kelder waren gehaald - zelf had hij deze jaargang nooit geproefd. De avond waar al deze bijzondere flessen werden ontkurkt was het jaarlijkse diner van de Académie du Vin de Bordeaux.

Het thema die avond: wijnen uit jaren eindigend op 8. Dus dronken we bij het eten achtereenvolgens Latour 1978, Mouton 1988, Lafite 1998, Haut-Brion 2008 en Yquem 2008, deels uit magnums en dubbele magnums. Het was een leerzame avond…

Bordeaux 2017 - Geheime lijst van ten onrechte nog niet uitverkochte wijnen

Bordeaux 2017 heeft niet dat warme broodjes over de toonbank gehalte van 2015 en 2016. De 2017 primeurs staan in de schaduw van die 2 monumentale jaren. Er zijn zeker goede wijnen gemaakt, maar de prijzen waren niet altijd aantrekkelijk. En veel kopers hadden de afgelopen 2 jaar ook al aardig in de buidel getast.

Toch zijn er koopwaardige 2017's. Natuurlijk zijn die er. Wijnen die het verdienen om eruit te worden gepikt. In onze laatste Bordeaux 2017 mailing hebben we de primeurs met de grootste prijsdaling op een rij gezet: een aantal toppers dat op een nette 20-26% prijsdaling zit.

In deze posting een iets ander lijstje: te weten dat van de wijnen die ten onrechte nog niet zijn uitverkocht, om wat voor reden dan ook.

Alter Ego de Palmer 2017.Pourquoi? Omdat deze wijn zo ongehoord goed is. De wijn heeft zeker goed verkocht, maar er zijn toch nog kelders in Nederland waarin Alter Ego 2017 over een paar jaar zal ontbreken... dat gaat ons niet gebeuren! Sterker: we zijn bezig om i…